The Magazine
How We Review
The blind table, the five criteria, and why we write prose instead of stars.
Home › The Magazine
Tips, corrections, letters, and jars for the tasting table — how to reach the editors, and what makes us open a note first.
Gourmet Gifts &c. is a small magazine with an open door. We read everything readers send, answer most of it, and act on more of it than you might expect. This page explains what to send where, and — because editors are human — what makes a note jump to the top of the pile.
We publish our method on the review page, and the method fails honestly: harvests change, mills change hands, our palates have off days like everyone's. A correction request should name the page, the claim, and your source. "Your honey guide says tupelo never crystallizes — mine just did, and here's the jar's origin" is a perfect correction; we will test, and if you are right, the page gets updated with a dated note. Corrections are never embarrassing. Unnoticed errors are.
We cover edible gifting and the art of the table: occasion guides, pantry explainers, regional American terroir, seasonal calendars, presentation, and the craft of feeding people well at every scale — from a jar to a convention floor. The tips we chase hardest name a specific place and a specific food: a mill, an orchard, a church-basement preserve economy, a regional candy that deserves its own guide like our terroir compass. The tips we cannot use are product launches without a place attached.
You may send food for consideration — but read the fine print first, because it protects you: everything enters the blind tasting table exactly like a purchased jar, unmarked vessels, three sittings, five criteria. We accept no payment for coverage, run no affiliate links, and do not sell placements. A sample buys a seat at the table, never a sentence in these pages. If your jar is the real thing, that policy is your best friend.
The best part of this job is the mail. Write us your family's gifting traditions, the jar that saved a visit, the regional pecan we missed, the housewarming gift you still talk about. We publish a short letters section when the volume earns it, with permission and names as you choose. Long letters from people who disagree with our cheese board ratios are handled with the respect they deserve.
So you know the trip your note takes: it lands in one shared inbox that the whole editorial team reads daily. Tips get a quick yes, no, or "send more" within the week; corrections get logged the same day and assigned a verdict cycle, because a claim on these pages is a claim we own. Product submissions get a polite acknowledgment and then silence for a while — that silence is the blind tasting table doing its work, three sittings and the five criteria, before anyone writes a sentence. Letters get read aloud to whoever is nearest the kettle; that has been policy since the first issue, and it will not change.
New here? The magazine's front door is the home page, and the fastest way to know us is the editor's letter and the guides it points to.
The Magazine
The blind table, the five criteria, and why we write prose instead of stars.
The Pantry
The regional map we are always redrawing — send us the valleys we missed.
By Occasion
The doctrine in one page: the occasion decides the food.